- I. Howard Marshall
I'm not sure where on the spectrum most of our (small) readership finds itself. This post is a rare political one and I'd like to make clear up front that I don't speak for all the Thinklings, only for myself. I also don't believe that salvation will ever happen through politics. Neither do I believe that one political party is perfect while the other one is evil, and I'm not heartless: I understand that living without health insurance is not a good thing and it's not my goal to deprive others of insurance.
With those caveats out of the way, a short back-story: I started my professional career working for a governmental agency. After four years of demoralizing (but easy!) work and an eye-opening baptism into the inefficiency, unexcellence and non-productivity of government-work, I got a job at a private company. The difference couldn't have been more stark. Things in the new company I worked at actually . . . worked (and I had to work hard to do my part). This experience has shaped many of my attitudes, rightly or wrongly.
In other words, my tourettes starts acting up anytime I'm assured that the Government can take on a large, complicated public service and that they will keep costs and debt under control while doing so. I don't hate the government. I just wish it would stick to what it does well, as enumerated in the Constitution. I don't distrust the government. I just don't think that it's very good at taking on large projects such as health-care. But I'd be willing to give it a shot if, like a business, failure to perform meant the ending of the activity. But that's not how government works.
As he often does, Mark Steyn is astute in his assessment of the 220 to 215 vote passage of a 1900+ page health care bill in the House of Representatives last night:
I don't like to say I told you so, but I've been saying for months now that the trick is to drag this thing across the finish line with 50.0000000000001 percent of the vote as soon as possible. From my "Happy Warrior" column in NR back in July:Obama believes in “the fierce urgency of now”, and fierce it is. That’s where all the poor befuddled sober centrists who can’t understand why the Democrats keep passing incoherent 1,200-page bills every week are missing the point. If “health care” were about health care, the devil would be in the details. But it’s not about health or costs or coverage; it’s about getting over the river and burning the bridge. It doesn’t matter what form of governmentalized health care gets passed as long as it passes. Once it’s in place, it will be “reformed”, endlessly, but it will never be undone.Right now, they can trade anything — abortion, death panels, whatever. The trick is to plant the seed and let the ratchet effect of Big Government take care of the rest. I said on Rush's show on Friday that if Barack Obama had been Bill Clinton he'd have woken up on Wednesday morning and begun triangulating. Instead, Obama woke up and figured that he needed more fierce urgency, and right now. The short-term hit in 2010 is worth it for the long-term benefits: Obscure congressmen will be just as happy as obscure ambassadors or obscure chairmen of obscure agencies. And the prize of permanent irreversible statist annexation merits the risk: Governmentalized "health care" puts us on the fast track to Euro-sclerosis and redefines the relationship between citizen and state in ways that make genuine conservative politics all but impossible.
Will the Senate stop it? And, if they don't, will a post-2010 GOP Congress reverse it? The way they reversed, say, the federal Department of Education?
Yesterday was a tragedy for America.
Trackback URL: http://thinklings.org/bloo.trackback.php/5648.
This post is a rare political one and I'd like to make clear up front that I don't speak for all the Thinklings, only for myself.
I thought the post was great. If my opinion counts for anything, I know alot of us culture warriors went off the deep end during the Clinton administration, but I don't think that negates the value of the culture war per se any more than a few unfortuntate food addicts in our society negate the value of a good breakfast. In the evangelical blogosphere there are more and more voices saying we shouldn't talk about politics and, more to the point, government, and those of us who want to do so seem to feel often obliged to apologize for it. (Don't mean to drag you into that, Bill.) But not me. So there!
if Barack Obama had been Bill Clinton he'd have woken up on Wednesday morning and begun triangulating. Instead, Obama woke up and figured that he needed more fierce urgency ...
Mark Steyn's a smart guy. I know that for sure now that he is saying what I have been thinking for a long time. My one sentence summary of Clinton's administration is that, when he saw he couldn't lead the country to the left, he decided to follow the polls to the right. But that's not going to happen now, I'm afraid.
my tourettes starts acting up anytime I'm assured that the Government can take on a large, complicated public service
Tourettes? I knew you were a good man, Bill. We should compare experiences some time. But anyway, this has all gotten a bit personal for me of late. A close family member of mine is now under the watchful care of the vaunted Canadian medial system. He has a tumor (thankfully benign) that needs removal. In the U.S., from the time you see the first G.P. until the time the specialist finally cuts the thing out, it would take, with a quite liberal estimate, a month at the most. He has been on their official government wait list for three months now, with no end in sight. Doctors in the Dakotas advertise in Canadian phone books to the effect of, "Can't see a doctor? You can see us! Come on down!" Mark Steyn himself recently had a similar story about a family member visiting him from England.
Well, that was long winded. But I'm done. (For now, heh heh.)
I heard a congressman this morning say he thought the bill would not pass the senate, and Mr. Lieberman said he would fight to keep the bill from coming to the floor for a final vote. But of course, the country is not doomed if the bill passes. It's just that people will suffer in a different way.
As Christians, we should pray for righteous leaders so that the good will prosper and the bad will be justly punished. I think there are many opportunities for Christians to take Christ the lost these days, and most of them are not political. Caring for orphans and widows, helping abused families and immigrants, rebuilding inner city families, using education opportunities to transform lives, stirring up a business by insisting on ethical decisions . . . and taking part in the political process by running for office and supporting some who are running.
But I'm rambling now, I guess.

I've been having my own problems with a federal government agency who can't seem to figure things out - and we're dealing with a relatively minor problem that has yet to be resolved. So far, it's taken app. three hours of my life spent on hold on the phone, speaking with people who don't know how to solve my problems, researching possible solutions on the internet, etc.
As I was on hold early this week, I thought to myself, "What if this is me trying to get clearance for a medical procedure five years from now or trying to get some clarification with what is covered once I'm taking part in the public "option"?" If the government can't be faithful with the small stuff, how can we trust them with 1.2 trillion dollars worth of health care initiative? augh.
Our hope, in regards to the health care bill, rests in the Senate. Do you think they will enact cloture just to pass this? I sure hope not, but - frankly - that's what I expect. It won't muster the 60-votes, if it includes the public option.
Last I heard, Reid was going to put his foot down against cloture as a political move to try and gain traction in his reelection campaign in his home state. I don't know if he is willing to be a sacrificial lamb for this, but he'll have a hard enough time getting re-elected outside of this bill. If health care passes, he's done for. And he'll drag his son down with him who is running for governor . . . I suppose if he really thinks it's the right thing to do, it might be worth throwing away any political legacy your family might have, but I don't know that he really believes in this.