"Why do people choose the substitute over God himself? Probably the most important reason is that it obviates accountability to God. We can meet idols on our own terms because they are our own creations. They are safe, predictable, and controllable; they are, in Jeremiah's colorful language, the 'scarecrows in a cornfield' (10:5). They are portable and completely under the user's control. They offer nothing like the threat of a God who thunders from Sinai and whose providence in this world so often appears to us to be incomprehensible and dangerous . . . [People] need face only themselves. That is the appeal of idolatry."

- David F. Wells
Homestead Heritage: Lessons I've Learned From An Agrarian Christian Community

Homestead Heritage is an agrarian Christian community a few miles north of Waco built around a fusion of Anabaptist tradition and Pentecostal theology. In 2005 Christian historian and theologian, Roger Olson, characterized the group as “a bold experiment” in intentional Christian community, and, as with any countercultural stream, the group has had its share of proponents and detractors.

For six years I’ve worked among these people for eight hours a day, Monday through Friday. My family and I have visited their craft village several times, dined in some of their homes, welcomed them into our home, and taken part in many of their special activities. We have friends in their community, we have friends who have almost joined their fellowship, and we have friends who have once been a part of their community, but, for whatever reason, decided to part ways. I believe we’ve seen them from just about every angle possible, without actually being part of their congregation.

With that said, this post isn’t about theology (though it will, at times, wax theological), and it’s not about what I disagree with them about, but rather it’s about what I’ve learned through them, and how I believe that my family and I have benefited in so many ways from the good, positive things that have been modeled through their day-to-day lives.

I’d like to also add that it’s not my intent to turn this into a forum for ex-members to discuss problems and disagreements with Homestead Heritage doctrine, practice, or theology. Therefore, please be aware that I will be moderating the comments (assuming this post actually generates comments).

Now, on to the point of my post: What I’ve learned from Homestead Heritage. The list is long and varied (I won’t list everything here), and, in reality, my wife and I have had many similar convictions to Homestead Heritage before we were ever acquainted with them (e.g. homeschooling, complementarianism, et cetera). This list is in no particular order:

Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?

That’s the question that Paul asked John the Baptist's Ephesian disciples in Acts 19:2, and, as one of the Thinklings’ patron saints, John Piper, has said, “Now that is a remarkable question for contemporary American evangelicals who have been taught by and large that the way you know you have received the Holy Spirit is that you are a believer” (see Piper’s sermon, What Does It Mean To Receive The Holy Spirit?). Homestead Heritage has helped me appreciate the fact that the baptism (or filling) of the Holy Spirit is, as Piper also said, “experiential, not just inferential.” When a Christian is filled with the Holy Spirit, he (and others) ought to know it. It’s not merely an inferential, theological position, but a manifested reality.

Like most branches of the Pentecostal tree, Homestead Heritage emphasizes “the Holy Ghost,” and unlike many thinkers from my childhood Baptist heritage (which I’m indebted to), they see the baptism in the Holy Spirit as a distinct, essential component of Christian discipleship that’s manifested in an experiential manner. To once again quote the incomparable Piper:

We scratch our heads and say, "I don't get it, Paul. If you assume we believed, why don't you assume we received the Holy Spirit? We've been taught that all who believe receive the Holy Spirit. We've been taught to just believe that the Spirit is there whether there are any effects or not. But you talk as if there is a way to know we've received the Holy Spirit different from believing. You talk as if we could point to an experience of the Spirit apart from believing in order to answer your question."

And that is in fact the way Paul talks. When he asks, "Did you receive the Spirit when you believed," he expects that a person who has "received the Holy Spirit" knows it, not just because it's an inference from his faith in Christ, but because it is an experience with effects that we can point to.


As Piper infers, it’s important to ask yourself the question Paul asked the Ephesians, and Homestead Heritage has, in many ways, helped me realize that.

Whatever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might ...

That’s what the Preacher of Ecclesiastes said, and working (or laboring) with all one’s might is a noble and valuable character trait for any Christian. As another founder of our feast, C.S. Lewis, said in Mere Christianity, “God is no fonder of intellectual slackers than He is of any other slacker.” Lewis’ point, I think, speaks to the idea that a strong work ethic is essential to Christian growth and discipleship, and I’m sure Lewis’ New Man (as described in the same book) would be someone who works for the joy of labor, as a means of communion with the Vinedresser (John 15:1), and not merely as a means to an end.

In other words, Homestead Heritage has taught me that work is a joy -- and, with that in mind, I believe work can be seen as something very similar to a sacrament. God is proactive, He’s creative, and His Gospel advances through the Kingdom of Darkness. God works, and so should we. What's more, we should work with joy. Our culture sees work as a way to get what it wants, and not as a way, as the 17th century monastery kitchen worker, Brother Lawrence, said, to “practice God’s presence.” (Brother Lawrence was continually in the presence of our Lord while doing his job -- washing dishes -- so much so that he said he saw no distinction between that time of work and fixed hours of prayer.)

For in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily (Colossians 2:9).

When the great -- though not uncontroversial! -- 20th century theologian Karl Barth visited America in 1962, he was asked to sum up his theology (which had been expressed in his voluminous Church Dogmatics), he responded, “Jesus loves me, this I know, for the Bible tells me so.” Homestead Heritage has reaffirmed a simple truth that I believe I have known since I was a child: that JESUS does love me, and that it’s alright -- necessary, even -- to worship Him in all His fullness. While I tend to doubt that Homestead Heritage’s theologians favor the often-misapprehended Barth, I think they’d agree wholeheartedly with his conclusion.

And Yahweh God planted a garden eastward in Eden, and there He put the man whom He had formed (Genesis 2:8).

A little over a year ago my wife and I bought a small 2-acre farm north of Waco. Since then we’ve tilled the ground, raised animals, slaughtered animals, worked the land, and have witnessed the ancient rhythms of life that humanity has been an intricate part of since Yahweh placed Adam in Eden. Out on a farm you feel seasons, you witness the principle of sowing and reaping first-hand, and you find a place of tranquility, being at one with God and His creation. It’s a beautiful life, and we wouldn’t trade it for the world. If we hadn’t met Homestead Heritage, we would have likely never pursued such an existence.

While I could think of many more examples, I won’t belabor the point: I have learned so much from an imperfect community of people who are, in many ways, strangers to me. My wife and I have, to some extent, walked among them, but we are not part of them. By no means do we believe that the fellowship is a panacea, but God has been faithful to allow us to learn from them, and to be all the better for it. We’re thankful. I’m thankful.

Trackbacks:

Trackback URL: http://thinklings.org/bloo.trackback.php/6092.

Comments on "Homestead Heritage: Lessons I've Learned From An Agrarian Christian Community":
1. Weekend Fisher - 08/13/2010 10:11 pm CDT

I've been curious about the modern homesteading movement. Were you able to support yourselves on 2 acres? Were you self-sustaining / save your own seeds for next season types? How long did it take you to get the knack of it, the whole more-natural lifestyle thing?

Take care & God bless
Anne / WF

2. Bird - 08/13/2010 10:25 pm CDT

Were you able to support yourselves on 2 acres?

We've only been at it for a little over a year, but I'll say we've gotten a significant amount of our food from our farm: all of our eggs, most of our chicken meat, and a decent amount of veggies (primarily tomatoes) here recently. But the reality is, no, we don't support ourselves primarily from our homestead, but we do have a long-term plan to get at least 75 percent of our sustenance from our property. I think it's a realistic goal, but it's going to take some years to develop.

We've found that for our needs 2 acres is more than enough. I'd say for most people's needs, 1 acre is plenty, and even half an acre (of good soil) could produce a ton of food. Honestly, right now we're only actively using 3/4 of an acre, and in that 3/4 acre area we have our home, shop, barn, and all of our animals so far. For the remaining 1.25 acres our plan is to fence off about an acre of it and raise goats (and maybe a calf at some point) out there. That'll leave us about 1/4 acre which we'll probably use as an orchard and a hay field. Again, we're just barely getting started. I think it'll take us 5 to 10 years to really get where we want to be.

Were you self-sustaining / save your own seeds for next season types?

Well, that's our goal. ;-)

How long did it take you to get the knack of it, the whole more-natural lifestyle thing?

As far as the diet, it came pretty naturally once we started eating whole, natural foods. Both my wife and I honestly and truly don't care much for fast food anymore (she "hates it," and I simply "don't prefer it"). We've raised our own chickens (and are currently raising ducks for meat as well); we eat our own free-range eggs; we drink raw, non-pasteurized milk; and we eat whole wheat bread products; etc. Oh, we also buy grass-fed beef from a local farmer who lives near us.

3. Bill - 08/14/2010 9:08 am CDT

Great post Bird. I've enjoyed over the past few years hearing about your rhythms of life on the farm (and your hospitality to my eldest) - looking forward to hearing more from you on this subject.

4. Whitney - 08/15/2010 7:38 am CDT

Hey,
I really appreciated this post; especially the filling of the Holy Spirit part. I will most likely seek out the Piper book you mentioned.

5. Bird - 08/15/2010 8:51 am CDT

Thanks, Billboy!

Whitney,

Thank you. You can actually click that link and listen to the sermon (it's a sermon, and not a book).

6. Whitney - 08/15/2010 5:57 pm CDT

Ahhh... yes, that's what I get for thinking/typing/holding a baby at the same time. :)

7. damien - 08/18/2010 8:41 am CDT

i am five years out from a bone marrow transplant for leukemia (which was successful). the most difficult part has been mental/emotional recovery from a very weakened and depressed state. 2010 has been a trying and blessed year with a huge family reunion in the mountains of virginia, and three of our six children getting married (with weddings). my wife and i have worked together planting and growing flowers and vegetables around our little home on the chesapeake bay. i have a ten foot high sunflower growing right outside the window i'm looking through as i type this. we put a hummingbird feeder outside the kitchen window and have just recently been treated to their regular visits. being involved with the natural world right here at my little homestead has been lifting my spirits more than anything else. i want so much to live on, meet grandchildren, and see new homes established for the glory of god and the spread of the gospel through my children and their spouses.

thy kingdom come, thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven.

8. Michele - 08/18/2010 3:13 pm CDT

Interesting post and website; I couldn't find a "What we believe" statement, however, and I'd be interested in one.

9. Bird - 08/18/2010 4:54 pm CDT

Michele, follow that link and go to "books." One of the books is a downloadable PDF book titled What We Believe.

10. Leann - 08/19/2010 2:50 pm CDT

I just found this website today (while doing a Google search on megachurches) and ended up reading this post. The thoughts this is provoking will end up on a post on my blog because it's way too much for a comment post. I'll sum it up with this: Some day I may run away to this Heritage community. Also, even though I only have .17 acres in a subdivision, I'm going to finally start that garden I've always said I wanted. Thanks for posting this! I look forward to hearing more about your life on the 2 acres.

11. Baaah - 03/22/2011 11:04 pm CDT

You haven't been around them my friend even to know that their theology is layers over layers, and that the most important layers are way too secret for a visitor to be trusted with.

You may not allow my post to go through, so that is your decision. I am therefore posting you directly and speaking to you directly. Email me anytime if you are curious what conclusions someone who has been around them for over a decade. I love many members there, and always wanted to believe the best about them. Christ's truth.

But some things may strike a chord even now. Some things just don't add up about them. Are you sure that their theology is open and stated? How about the literature? Have you access to all of their writings and publications? I think not.

I agree that even a visitor can glean fruit from their tree. All I am saying is that you have no idea about some things they believe and practise.
Word.

12. Bird - 03/23/2011 6:24 am CDT

Thanks for your comment, Baaah.

Leave a Comment:
Name:
URL: (optional)
Email: (optional - will not be published)
Comment:

Please enter the characters you see in the above CAPTCHA image:


Notify me via email if any followup comments are added to this post (show help)